Astaneh Construction vs JP Lucky Construction And Roofing: which fits a custom home build?
The differences that matter
- Project scale and scope. Astaneh's review history centers on whole-home gut jobs, kitchen and basement renovations at a scale that maps directly onto custom home work, while JP Lucky's portfolio leans on roofing, bathrooms, and remodels with full renovations as one of several service lines.
- Project management structure. Astaneh names a dedicated project manager, Rana, who coordinates communication and site efficiency across a full build, whereas JP Lucky's Wendy is praised for responsive phone and email support rather than on-site build coordination.
- Speed vs depth of build. JP Lucky's standout trait is finishing projects in days rather than weeks, a strength suited to renovations and repairs but less relevant when a custom home build runs months and depends on sequencing many trades.
- Subcontractor handling. Astaneh explicitly vets subcontractors and treats them as partners, a detail that matters on a custom build where multiple trades need to mesh under one schedule, while JP Lucky's crew praise (James, Nic) centers on individual skill and flexibility rather than subcontractor management.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Astaneh Construction: 5 (118 reviews)
- JP Lucky Construction And Roofing: 4.9 (148 reviews)
- Services
- Astaneh Construction: kitchen renovation, bathroom renovation, basement renovation, home additions
- JP Lucky Construction And Roofing: kitchen renovation, basement renovation, home additions, whole home renovation
- Best fit project type
- Astaneh Construction: Whole-home builds and gut renovations
- JP Lucky Construction And Roofing: Roofing, remodels, and faster-turnaround renovations
- Site coordination style
- Astaneh Construction: Dedicated project manager overseeing trades and schedule
- JP Lucky Construction And Roofing: Responsive office contact plus flexible on-site crew
- Verification
- Astaneh Construction: Google-verified
- JP Lucky Construction And Roofing: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Astaneh Construction: 92
- JP Lucky Construction And Roofing: 92
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Astaneh Construction
Reviewers consistently report stress-free renovations completed on time and on budget. Hamed and his team, particularly project manager Rana, combine clear daily communication with honest pricing and meticulous work.
Home and kitchen renovations, basement finishes, and whole-home gut jobs all drew five-star praise. Subcontractors are vetted and respected. One photographer noted Hamed's rare combination of organization, high materials standards, and reliability across the construction field.
JP Lucky Construction And Roofing
From quote to finished project, JP Lucky moves fast and keeps you in the loop. Wendy handles communication smoothly, crews show up on schedule, and quality shows in both the structure and the finishing touches. Neighbors compliment the results. The team also responds within hours to any post-project issue, walking roofs and adjusting work without delay or upsell pressure.
Work spans roofing, bathroom and basement gutters, kitchen remodels, and full house renovation. Homeowners consistently mention clean sites, no scope creep, and final costs matching estimates. A few long-term clients note reliability over years of repeated projects. Staff including James and Nic are named in praise for their skill and willingness to accommodate site changes.
Which should you pick?
Pick Astaneh Construction if
- You're planning a full custom home or whole-house gut renovation with multiple trades to sequence
- You want a named project manager keeping daily communication tight across a long build
- You value vetted subcontractors treated as partners over a multi-month project
Pick JP Lucky Construction And Roofing if
- Your project is a renovation or addition rather than a ground-up custom build
- Speed matters more than scale, and you want the job wrapped up in days, not months
- You want fast post-project response and warranty follow-up on a completed job
Verdict
Astaneh Construction is the better match for a genuine custom home build: its review history is built on whole-home projects with a named project manager coordinating trades over the long haul, which is exactly the skill set a custom build demands. JP Lucky Construction And Roofing earns its reputation on speed and responsiveness, strong for renovations, roofing, and remodels, but its fast-turnaround model is a less natural fit for the sustained, multi-trade sequencing a custom home requires.
Can't decide which contractor is right for you?
Tell us about your project and get quotes from qualified renovation contractor in Greater Toronto Area.
Enquiries from our contact forms may go to partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings are based on our published scoring method only and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which contractor has more experience with full custom builds specifically?
- Astaneh Construction's review data points to whole-home gut jobs and full renovations as a core part of its work, with a project manager named specifically for coordinating those larger builds.
- Is JP Lucky Construction And Roofing able to handle a custom home build at all?
- Its praise covers full house renovation among other services, so it can take on larger projects, but its standout strength in the data is fast turnaround on renovations and roofing rather than long-sequence custom builds.
- Does either business have a rating or review count edge?
- JP Lucky has a slightly higher review volume at 148 versus 118, and Astaneh has a marginally higher rating at 5.0 versus 4.9, but both scores are close enough that project fit matters more than the numbers.